Darktable vs lightroom reddit11/8/2023 I've not worked with Darktable so, don't know how you'd mask/manage sharpening in that app. Plus, you'll mitigate other sharpening artifacts. Darktable vs Lightroom For any of you with experience in both softwares, Do you use both software If not, why did you decide to use Lightroom It looks like Lightroom is more user friendly, but has fewer features if you dig. Keywords are also better in Lightroom, and it also has the overall edge in capability. Where Lightroom presents a simple UI that feels very intuitive, Darktable requires a learning curve. Also, noise in the sky and water won't be as obvious. The overall UI of Darktable is still a disadvantage for me because I tend to move around a lot, trying to find commands and tools. (The sky and water look sharpened.) In Lightroom, if you apply a mask to limit sharpening only to the land, the detail rendering will be improved. Looking at the two images, it appears sharpening was globally applied to both. It's a gorgeous scene and must've been fun to photograph. It seems like an ongoing process to get the best Fuji RAW converter. Your example to me though with Darktable looks quite unnatural almost HDR like. Lightroon may even automatically add some selective noise reduction to raised. Shadows will always contain less light, and therefore (relatively) more noise than highlights. Noise is caused by lack of light (less energy, smaller SNR). The first image was developed with Lightroom 6.6.1 and the second one with Darktable 2.4.0. Thats because Lightroom always applies noise reduction, even when the noise reduction slider is at zero. I doesn't affect the quality of the details though. I tried to somewhat mimic the Lightroom processing of the file, but since I've never used Darktable before, the output is a bit off, especially regarding the colors. Here is a comparison with Lightroom of an image shot with a Fuji X-T1. ![]() ![]() I have to say I'm very impressed by its demosaicing of Fuji X-Trans files!Īfter having tried Capture One, Luminar, Iridient X-Transformer and RawTherapee, I find Darktable to give the best details and overall quality. In my quest of finding a Lightroom replacement, I just gave Darktable a shot without really considering it as a viable alternative.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply.AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |